Comments (Page 601)

Thanks Allotitan :)

After 245 pages of the same arguments, it's about time ;)

Oh man! Even the spino v rex thread is quite!

We all seem to do giant brawls at some point. Mine was Dinosaur Massacre. Good job on this, rooting for Rex :)

True, it is plausible.

My take is that there's animlas like Aregentinosaurus sauropodsiden, pralititan and many others as well as huge carnivores such as Giganotosaurus, Tyrannosaurus, Carcharadontosaurus and many others. 

Thanks Carnosaur, I like to try fights that are as different from the usual as possible :)

thats sad

amphiceolias

Moose FTW..wait....it lost? damn...

Anyways, i'm enjoying these a good deal. Original take is always refreshing!

it hasn't been too active lately, i posted about the new ornithiscian a couple days ago, usualy there's a lot of people with something to say but lately, not really

Except for the abelisaurs. Plus raptors. Their arms are kind of skinny.

As of right now, yes that's true. But We have Amphicoelias(?) Apatosaurus - which got a huge size upgrade possibly(i'll post a discussion) Brachiosaurus, Giraffatitan, And a myriad of titanosaurs.

The largest animals to ever walk the earth roamed the jurassic, something had to feed off of them and keep their populations in check. And i doubt a pack of A. Fragillis would be able to touch brachiosaurus, let alone Giraffatitan. I could be wrong though, time will tell i guess

Thanks MrHappy and I really appreciate that Cat :)

Not sure which to root for, but this tone around, I was rooting for Deinonychus. Good fight. 

Yep it is huge, however is it active. It seems to be slowly lessing or something, I might be wrong though :)

i like , i love your figths they are the most fun and originall in the site

Glad you guys liked it.

yes, but i think the ones with an unsavory biased against tyrannosaurs are no loner active there(banned or otherwise) neat little forum, really

yep there are some rex haters, but spino haters too.

Then again, there was a lot of huge sauropods from the cretaceous, and the biggest predators we have are all from the cretaceous.

there are some rex haters there too

do note that the biggest theropods probably come from the jurassic period. Something's gotta be big enough to kill those sauropods

The consensus over there is they now believe spino wasn't as big as they previously thought...and i'm pretty sure theres a 'register' button up in the top right corner

Sometimes they are, towards both dinos. They say stuff like OMG SPINO IS 20m LONG and 20tons, ONE SWIPE KILL DA TREX! and vise versa! But alot of people are actually very knowledge filled! 

hopefully

i like it and rooted for deino

Awesome fight, was rooting for Deinoychus.

rooting for the grizzly bear next time! 

plausible, but then again that's just my working hypothesis. Surely, an animal of the supposed initial 15 meters would have been described by now! It's been almost 17 years since it was described

how do u join

They already did

Spinosaurus on Carnivora

that forum hasn't been very active lately though. I try to post a lot on there :D

they arent biased

If it was 6 tons the other big three would have it outclassed in weight for sure. 

Interesting carnosaur... So Das monster might have just been a mix of megalosaur and pilosaur bones....

I haven't tried, they seem quite bais towards animals and Dino's.

wow so much to read

ikr i would but i cant join the fourm.

Das monster von minden is a sketchy theropod. There are claims of banana sized teeth and ribs 1,5 size of Allosaurus(If that realy holds true, who knows?) at the site, aswell as the rather small skull. Years ago I saw a pic of a reconstructed skull that looked very much like Torvosaurus´. So the smaller specimen seems to be a Megalosaurid. Probably no one knows what the larger parts may be? Maybe be even a Chimera (Pliosaur teeth?).

There's a german National Geographic article from 1999, which mentioned the rib to be 50% larger, but appearently, there are no other sources for that size. I can't find that article, but I fear this could be again a media exaggeration. There's no sciencifitic description, a media article can easily make the rib larger than it is.
In Holtz Genus list, that dinosaur was just 12m long.

Also, Mickey Mortimer downgraded that thing quite substaintially in the size department:

" ~7-8 m; 750 kg-1.2 tons) (skull ~1.0 m) premaxilla, maxilla (517 mm),

I think that was from planet dinosaur. AND WHHHHAT! 6 tons and that short, I think It might be outclasses by the other big three! My god, can't wait until someone brings this up on carnivoria!

uhhhhhh,it had a resemblence to both megalosaurid and allosaurid

ya,so i guess most heropod hads had strong arms?