Sniper
MemberCompsognathusJan-18-2014 4:05 AMEverybody know here whos is the three big.The biggest question about them is that who owns the dinosaurs crown.Well…let’s see
Iin the real life none of them met because they live in different time,and different place.
The biggest problem in this question that people always want to answer this question with a fight until dead.But the carnivores not as stupid to fight without an important reason.Most of the fights possibly not more than the rivals roar to the other,running circles,and try to scare away the other,and only fight if this scary tactic doesn’t work,and i’m sure that not until death.A carnivore could recognize if it going to lose if it continiue the fight so a fight that end with death is uncommon,at least if not the hungry carnivore going to win,because im sure that it won’t let the other to run away .I want to say with this that the common fights not end in death.
Now let’s see them
At first i show a comparasion by scott hartman(only because i want to show that how fragmentary the giganotosaurus and spinosaurus,and thats why im not going to talk about inteligence)
Spinosaurus:
weapons:huge claws,crocodile like teeth.
the spinosaur could be one of the most bizarre predator with it’s sail.the fuction of this sail is unknow,but i could imagine that it could turn this sail’s colour to red if it met with an other predator,just like the stegosaurus could do.with this movement it seems more bigger and more scary.
the spinosaur’s size is unknown,the scientists put it between 15 and 17m.that’s not small,especially because in the word of carnivores usually enought if the other longer and taller than it’s rival.and this help to scare away the rival without one of them damaged.and if the fight happen it could use it claws to attack the other,and one lucky hit on the head,and one eye gone,or possibly kill the rival.
Giganotosaurus:
weapons:teeth that work like steak knifes,speed
the giganotosaurus could be the sauropods nightmare.this giant’s total size is unknown too just like the spinosaurus.the scientists put it between 13 and 15m.it could live in packs that work together,and could kill every dinosaur.
the giganotosaurus the biggest carnivore in it’s ecosystem,but they are fast too.it’s fight tactic could be that ambush it’s prey,bite large meat peaces,going to a sefe position and to this again and again untill it made enough damage to kill the prey.and using it speed it could hit it’s rival with it’s head just like the allosaurus do in prehistoric fight club.but because it’S teeth are perfect to cut the stomach could be a common target too.
tyrannosaurus:
weapons:banana like teeth that able to break bone,big head
unlike the other two predator there are complete skeletons like sue.because that we know a lot of information about it.it’s not fast but it’s bite force is the strongest(that’s not surprise if it hunt armored dinosaurs like triceratops).the scientists put its size between 12,5 and 13,5m.they could live in family groups,and the faster juvenilles lure the prey toward the slow adult’s.
the tyrannosauru’s most common target could be the neck.with it’s huge bite force it could easily kill the rivals but that’s not always work(the t.rex grab it in wrong position,or the prey moves too much,and the t.rex isn’t able to bite withe the force that it need).
other big predators in the ecosystem:
this is an important thing too because if there are more big predators around they have more chance to win because they know how to handle other big predators.
spinosaurus:in the spinosaurus’s ecosystem is only one predator that could mess with it,the carcharodontosaurus,that could as long as a t.rex.
giganotosaurus:there are three big predators in the giganotosaurus’s ecosystem.all of the are bigger than 10m and werry dangerous.they are the megaraptor,oxalaia and ekrixinatosaurus.
tyrannosaurus:there aren’t any big predator in the t.rex’s ecosystem.this is because all of them extinct before it.the carcharodontosaurs extinct with acrocantosaurus,the megaraptors extict with siats and there are no abelisaurs in north.the only big predator is an other t.rex
other that could decide who win:
-motivation
-weather(the dry season made more dangerous the fight)
-previously get injures
-age
-experience
-agression
-size
Since there are many variations between the others i can say that all of them could be the king of dinosaur’s,but that’s impossible to say that who.they are able to kill the other.
Lord Vader
MemberTyrannosaurus RexJan-18-2014 5:11 AMGood job on this. My opinion is still that Rex is King, but good job on this comparison of the big three.
Jack of all trades. Master of none
Lord Vader
MemberTyrannosaurus RexJan-18-2014 5:21 AMAnytime.
Motivation can be huge factor. If Spinosaurus invades a T-Rex's paddock and it has a nest, Spino is screwed, or viese versa if a Rex invades a Spinosaurus's territory and it has a nest. At parity in a normal fight for territory or something, I say Rex would win most of the time (at length parity, say 45 feet).
Jack of all trades. Master of none
Sniper
MemberCompsognathusJan-18-2014 5:30 AMThats true.but as i said there are too much variation between the others so thats impossible to say who wins more.but i agree with you.
Lord Vader
MemberTyrannosaurus RexJan-18-2014 5:37 AMThe size variation (or POTENTIAL size variaiton) is the big thing that could give Giga and maybe Spino an edge over Rex. Giga and Spino are known from such fragmentary remains that their sizes can't be accurately measuered. I still say Rex is the King no matter what, and no one can change my opinion.
Jack of all trades. Master of none
Sniper
MemberCompsognathusJan-18-2014 5:41 AMi dont want to change your opinion if you mean this.everyone have an own opinion,i dont want to change it,just tell my opinion.
Lord Vader
MemberTyrannosaurus RexJan-18-2014 5:45 AMAnd you did a good job of stating your opinion.
Jack of all trades. Master of none
Rex Fan 684
MemberCompsognathusJan-18-2014 8:26 AMDo I agree with everything stated? No. But that's to be expected. You did forget that T-rex lived alongside Deinosuchus and Sarcosuchus was present in Africa and possibly S. America for Giga and Spino.
PS- Megaraptor's closer to 8 meters, not 10.
Sniper
MemberCompsognathusJan-18-2014 11:28 AMDinoSteve93
MemberCompsognathusJan-18-2014 1:02 PMGreat comparison of those big three, well put up "facts".
I son't exactly agree with all the statements, but they are acceptable, from my point of view. Very nice topic, overall.
Proud founder of the site Theropods Wiki! www.theropods.wikia.com
Gojira2K
MemberCompsognathusJan-18-2014 1:27 PMNice comparison. I agree with most of what you said, but in my mind in a fight Spinosaurus would win, but given the right conditions he could lose horribly by both T-Rex and Giga. And the same withe both of them. It just depends on the conditions of the fight. I also agree with most every thing all of you said.
"There is nothing noble in being superior to your fellow man; true nobility is being superior to your former self." - Ernest Hemingway.
Sniper
MemberCompsognathusJan-18-2014 2:07 PMSinornithosaurus
MemberCompsognathusJan-18-2014 5:26 PMSpinosaurus is well accustomed to dealing with Charcharodontosaurus, so a Giga ahoulsn't be much trouble.
A tyrannosaur would probably be intimidated by the Spinosaur's size and forfeit.