Jurassic World Movie News

Scaling up poorly known dinosaurs: a bad idea?

Carnosaur

MemberCompsognathusJanuary 18, 20141282 Views5 Replies

this was bugging the hell out of me. Why would world renowned, respected paleontologists just take an' educated' GUESS on a poorly known animals size, and just base it off of 'close' relatives? how can you sit there and say ' oh it was this big and this heavy when you have so little? My main example? Spinosaurus.

This is what they have found, a partial skull, a few tall spines, and teeth in sockets. really? how do you get this:

'Picture positive': Lost photos confirm fossil find

to this??

now, i've heard rumors they found parts of a leg bone not that long ago, and studies are being conducted on it. Can't find anything on this.

Now, i see why someone would use a 'scaled up' baryonyx or even perhaps suchomimus. Sure, you can argue all day it's a decent idea. It has a resemblance to these animals, yes. But say for example the komodo dragon was only known from skeletal remains let's say, a partial lower jaw, 9 inches long.Photo: Komodo dragon

So using say a mangrove monitor, (something less long and skinnier, yet closely related) has a complete skull of around 10 inches.  scaling the whole body, and reconstructing the 'correct' skeletal structure, put The Komodo  dragon at 15 + feet and 600 or more pounds for an average! come on now...they get on average 10 feet and 300 lbs. so this is my point..The  truth is, we have next to nothing of this monstrous animal. A few photographs of some very partial remains. new finds are Even less then that picture above! I just don't see enough to support the suggestion of a 60 foot, 23 ton monster with a sail. you can't claim to know an animals natural ecosystem and what it did, or even what it looked like with such scant remains (as planet dinosaur did). We can do this with abelisaur, tyrannosaurs, or even megalosaurs because there has simply been more discovered. Size ranges established, niches classified. The complete opposite with spinosaurs.

This...is just my thought on the matter. I'm not hating on old spiny, and if you take offense, well...i honestly don't care. Feel free to leave your comments below, i would love to see what you guys think.

Nature doesn't deceive us; it is we who deceive ourselves.

User Avatar
Lord Vader
Group: Member
Rank: Tyrannosaurus Rex
View Profile

Those are good points. I agree with you.

Jack of all trades. Master of none

User Avatar
Rex Fan 684
Group: Member
Rank: Compsognathus
View Profile

I agree with what was said here. I usually estimate Spinosaurus to be roughly 14-17 meters in length and 4-8 tons or so in weight.

 

Poorly Done Size Comparisons(in my opinion)

 

 

 

Skulls(accuarate in my opinion)

 

Some accuraute comparisons(in my opinion)

 

 

"Men like me don't start the wars. We just die in them. We've always died in them, and we always will. We don't expect any praise for it, no parades. No one knows our names." ―Alpha-98
User Avatar
Sci-Fi King25
Group: Member
Rank: Allosaurus
View Profile

Cool RexFan. The 3rd inaccurate picture you could really tell it was fake. I'm on Team Spino, but I know Spino wasn't THAT big. It was probably 50-58 ft. long and about 28-30 feet tall (Including sail). I wouldn't say the size comparisons are too accurate.

“Banana oil.”- George Takei, Gigantis: The Fire Monster

User Avatar
Rex Fan 684
Group: Member
Rank: Compsognathus
View Profile

Yeah. It was big, but I don't think it was 60+ feet and 20+ tons. 

"Men like me don't start the wars. We just die in them. We've always died in them, and we always will. We don't expect any praise for it, no parades. No one knows our names." ―Alpha-98
User Avatar
Carnosaur
Group: Member
Rank: Compsognathus
View Profile

i believe it was a big animal, and i agree with you rexfan. I don't see anything supporting a 60ft.+ animal.

Nature doesn't deceive us; it is we who deceive ourselves.

Join the discussion!



Latest Media
Join the discussion!
Please sign in to access your profile features!
(Signing in also removes ads!)



Forgot Password?
Scified Website LogoYour sci-fi community, old-school & modern
Hosted Fansites
AlienFansite
GodzillaFansite
PredatorFansite
Main Menu
Community
Sci-Fi Movies
Help & Info
+

Sign In to contribute!